Declan O’Donnell, Sunday, 7-22-12 July 22, 2012Posted by The Space Show in Uncategorized.
Tags: " SpaceX, Chinese Space Program, commercial space, Common Heritage of Mankind, Declan O'Donnell, EU Code of Conduct for Outer Space Activities., International Space Development Authority (ISDAC), land leases, Law of the Sea Treaty, Liability treaty, Moon Treaty, NewSpace, property rights, space debris, Spitsbergen Treaty, Svalbard Treaty, tort reform, United Societies In Space (USIS)
Declan O’Donnell, Sunday, 7-22-12
Guest: Declan O’Donnell. Topics: USIS updates, Law of the Sea Treaty, space settlement, property rights & more. You are invited to comment, ask questions, and discuss the Space Show program/guest(s) on the Space Show blog, https://thespaceshow.wordpress.com. Comments, questions, and any discussion must be relevant and applicable to Space Show programming. Transcripts of Space Show programs are not permitted without prior written consent from The Space Show (even if for personal use) & are a violation of the Space Show copyright. Declan O’Donnell returned for legal updates with United Societies In Space (USIS), the Intentional Space Development Authority (ISDAC), Law of the Sea Treaty, property rights and much more. Declan suggested the best websites to visit for more information would be http://space-law.org/ISDAC/ISDAC.html and www.internationalspacedevelopment.com. During this segment, Declan talked about the various UN space treaties, including the Liability Treaty and space debris issues. Next, I asked Declan about the renewed interest show by the U.S. in the ratification of the Law of the Sea Treaty (LOST). Like many others, Declan clearly spelled out the problems with this treaty and the problems with the common heritage of mankind ideology, especially for space settlement and commerce. He said if LOST is ratified by the Senate, it would be a “dangerous precedent.” Declan spent time going into the history of LOST and we talked about it being bottled up in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee (www.foreign.senate.gov). Related issues discussed in this segment and throughout the program dealt with problems in enforcing treaties of all kinds. Declan talked about the role of USIS and ISDAC regarding LOST and the ownership of space property issues. He even talked about these organizations proposing a new treaty to support growth & the commercial development of space. Andrew called in to talk about the 1920 Svalbard Treaty as a possible model for space. You can read about this treaty at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svalbard_Treaty.
Our second segment started with Tim calling to ask if there were other organizations promoting LOST and/or The Moon Treaty other than the U.N. Later, Declan was asked about the Chinese space program and we again referenced issues with the Liability Treaty and Chinese caused space debris issues. Also in this segment, Declan was asked about the EU Code of Conduct for Outer Space Activities. Note that he confirmed it was risky to dismiss such things because of the voluntary aspect & he cited several examples to illustrate his point. He even talked about a specific Italian jurisdictional clause for a local region often inserted in contracts and used as a set of rules for litigation. Harry emailed out guest about the spaceport no liability laws that have been adopted by several states. Declan had much to say about this and the issue of liability. Interestingly, he said the waiver that we hear so much about and that is required in the federal law is more about protecting the U.S. Government given it has the ultimate liability for everything launched into space in the U.S. & possibly with U.S. hardware elsewhere in the world as the U.S. would be considered by treaty the launching state. Near the end of our program, I mentioned a SF Business Times article on space investment in Silicon Valley. I will upload the .pdf to the blog for those interested in reading it. Marshall also emailed in a question on the liability issue regarding a spacecraft landing in a different country from its launching country. As the program was ending, Declan talked about USIS and ISDAC membership & given his being a trial lawyer, I asked him about the controversial issue in healthcare of tort reform. You might be surprised by his answer.
Post your questions/comments on The Space Show blog. You can email Declan through me at firstname.lastname@example.org
You can read the SF Business Times article mentioned on the show here: